10 Things All New Parents Should Know

by phdinparenting on August 4, 2008 · 72 comments

As parents, we’ve all made mistakes. We’ve all seen other parents make mistakes. In some cases, the mistakes are due to poor information and in other cases just poor judgement. The poor judgement part is, in my mind, just part of learning the art of parenting. It is something you learn through experience and by observing like-minded parents and hopefully your judgement improves with time.

But poor information is a problem. The science of parenting continues to evolve. We know better now about a lot of things and therefore do things differently than our parents did. However, a lot of people turn to their parents, their older siblings, friends with older children, and other trusted people in their lives for advice on raising their children. Or they just get given the advice, unsolicited.

With the intent of dispelling some of the misinformation out there, I put together a list of the things that I think all new parents should know (of course, I’ll check the most recent studies before giving this same advice to my kids as they embark on parenthood in a few decades time!).

10 Things Every New Parent Should Know

1. You cannot spoil a child with love: So many new parents hear well-meaning people telling them that they are spoiling their baby by holding him and responding to his needs. But you cannot spoil a child with love. You can only spoil a child by giving the child stuff as a replacement for the time and attention that you are not able to give your child. This great article discusses the issue in more detail: Am I Spoiling My Child?

2. You should be responsive to your child’s cries:Your baby does not need to exercise her lungs. She doesn’t need to learn to self-soothe. What she needs are parents that understand that a baby’s cry is her only way of communicating with you and she uses it to tell you that she needs something or that she needs you. It is important to respond to your baby’s cries both to meet her most basic needs and to give her a sense of security that she will carry through life. Excessive crying can be harmful to babies. Another part of being responsive to your child is watching for cues (crying is the last cue – once the others have been missed!) to tell you when your baby is hungry and when she is tired. You don’t need to implement a schedule for feeding and for sleep, you should watch your baby instead to determine when feeding and sleeping times should be.

3. Discipline means teach: New parents worry that they need to “discipline” their child. But often when they say discipline, they mean spanking or punishing. However, the word discipline means to teach. That is what parents need to do. They need to guide and teach their children. In the same way that we do not expect a first grader to learn calculus, it is important to understand what age appropriate behaviour is and to shape your expectations of your child and your discipline (teaching) according to what a child can reasonably be expected to understand at any given age.

4. The World Health Organization recommends breastfeeding for 2 years or beyond: So many mothers think that they need to start weaning when their baby gets teeth. Or they need to wean when they introduce solid foods. Or they need to wean when they go back to work. This last one is the one I hear most often here in Canada where we have one year maternity leave. I hear mothers that loved breastfeeding talk about how they have to wean because they are going back to work. That is not the case. Moms can continue breastfeeding on demand when they are with the baby and just not nurse while at work during the day. They can, of course, choose to pump while at work (I still pump once per day for my daughter who is 16 months, but I stopped pumping at 1 year with my son), but they don’t have to. Breastfeeding doesn’t have to be all or nothing, it is possible to set limits or to partially wean, but still keep nursing in certain situations or at certain times of day. I think if more mothers knew this, more of them might be willing to nurse up to the WHO recommendation of 2 years or beyond. I recognize that not all mothers want to nurse for that long and that some babies do self-wean before that age. However, I think it is too bad when mothers that want to continue nursing feel that they have to stop earlier. Personally, I do everything in my power to keep my kids nursing until they are 2 years old and at that point, it is up to them to decide when they want to stop.

5. Solid food is not recommended before at least 6 months: Over the years, the recommendation on when to introduce solid foods has changed. I was given pablum at 6 weeks. But today, experts recommend exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months, followed by slow introduction of solid foods. As explained in the link, this gives babies greater protection from illness and food allergies, it gives their digestive system time to mature, helps protect from obesity, and many other benefits.

6. Your doctor is not a parenting expert and usually not a breastfeeding expert: I hear of so many new parents that feel bad after they leave their doctors office. It isn’t because their baby isn’t healthy. It is because the doctor was giving them advice on parenting issues like how and where they baby sleeps, how they deal with night wakings, how they discipline their children, and so on. Even on issues that are medical issues, listen to your doctor but do your own research too and don’t be afraid to get a second opinion. I have heard of many doctors that express concern about any baby that is not above the 50th percentile on the growth charts and start suggesting formula supplements. Hmm…50% of all babies are below the 50th percentile. Are half of our babies really at risk of starving? Also, it sometimes takes time for recommendations to trickle down to your doctor’s office. A lot of doctors still aren’t aware of the recommendation that solids only be introduced at 6 months of age. A lot of them are still using the old growthcharts for formula fed babies instead of the new charts for breastfed babies. A lot of them only had very minimal training on breastfeeding to begin with.  If your doctor is raising concerns about the feeding of your baby, consider seeing an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant. They are medical professionals with significant training and experience in breastfeeding.

7. You can sleep safely with your baby: There has been a lot of publicity about co-sleeping being dangerous. I addressed a lot of those myths in my post Faulty logic from the Ontario coroner regarding bed sharing. However, if you implement a few simple guidelines, then it can be safe to sleep with your baby and can even be safer than putting your baby in a crib in a separate room.

8. Obesity is going to be the biggest health problem facing our children’s generation: They say fat is the new tobacco, meaning it will have the greatest negative impact on the health of the next generation. We need to give our children a good head start by making the right choices about infant feeding to avoid obesity and then continue to feed our children healthy foods that are low in sugar and low in saturated fats.

9. Children need to connect with nature: When we were kids, we roamed the neighbourhood without our parents. We climbed trees, picked berries, played in the dirt, built forts, caught frogs, and had a great time. We learned about nature by being part of nature. Today, parents are scared to let their kids go out on their own, so that means they keep them inside. They watch TV, they play on the computer, they go to organized sports or other activities. But free outdoor play time is rarer and rarer. If parents don’t want to let their kids roam unsupervised (I know I don’t…not yet at least!), then they need to go with them and let their child take the lead. Let them play freely in nature. Let them touch nature. Let them get exercise and fresh air at the same time. Want to read more? Get Last Child in the Woods: Saving Our Children from Nature Deficit Disorder.

10. Keep your child rear-facing in the car for as long as possible: A lot of parents ask when they can turn their child around and then turn them around as soon as they have met the minimum guidelines for height, weight and age. However, you should keep your child rear-facing for as long as possible, i.e. at least until they reach the height and weight limit of the car seat while rear facing (but possibly considering buying a new seat if that would mean turning the baby too soon). More information here: Why rear facing is safest.

Once you’ve done your research and made your decisions about how you want to parent, there are always going to be people that will try to tell you what you are doing is wrong. Some of them are well meaning, some of them are not. But none of them are you. Sometimes you may welcome advice and even seek it out. Other times you may want people to leave you alone. Regardless of whether the advice is solicited or not, you need to learn to take what works for you and leave the rest. Be confident! And if someone keeps bothering you and won’t let up, ask them to “pass the bean dip“.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

{ 65 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Cynthia August 4, 2008 at 11:55 pm

My neck is sore from all the vigorous nodding I did while reading this. Very well said.

Reply

2 annie August 5, 2008 at 7:51 am

This is fantastic. I am spreading it around.

Reply

3 phdinparenting August 5, 2008 at 2:16 pm

annie: Thanks! please do share…

Reply

4 Nerida August 5, 2008 at 11:57 pm

Great stuff!

I particularly like the points on not being able to spoil kids with love and that discipline is about teaching not punishing.

Reply

5 amyandsimon August 6, 2008 at 11:59 am

I wish more people would realize these things. Thanks for putting it out there!

Reply

6 mommylounge August 6, 2008 at 5:23 pm

You make some good points. I especially agree with the fact that too discipline means to teach. As a child I wasn’t “taught” much except through spanking so I never really learned the difference between right and wrong; just caught and not. As a Mom now I want to teach my children to respect our family values and respect people. I will never use spanking as a form of discipline. It does get hard to have patience with a whiny two year old, but like you said we have to understand the childs age appropriate behavior. I also really agree with letting my children explore nature and just be. I had heard a story about how the children growing up need to feel connected to nature in order for them to truly appreciate it and want to take care of our world.
Thanks for coming by our blog too. I do think that babywearing is important also. I wore my eldest in a sling until I was too pregnant too carry her and then my youngest practically lived in my sling while she was a newborn so that I could run after my 14 mo old at the time. It is just the most natural for a baby to be close to their mother. You don’t see other animals carrying their babies around in carseats!
Great blog–I’ll be back another time!
Kalisha

Reply

7 Isil August 6, 2008 at 5:36 pm

Coming from Half Pint Pixie.
Great blog!I’ll be back when I have some more time.

Reply

8 geriatricmama August 7, 2008 at 5:07 pm

This is great information! Although, regarding #5, the AAP did change it’s guidelines earlier this year allowing for infants from 4-6 months up to eat “high allergen” foods, providing their family doesn’t have a history of food allergies. Their update can be seen here: http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;121/1/183

Thanks for the great blogs!

Reply

9 phdinparenting August 7, 2008 at 10:52 pm

@ geriatricmama:

Thank you for your comment. The link that you provided only address the allergy risk factor. However, there are many other reasons for waiting until 6 months to introduce solid foods (as listed in the link that I provided). The rationale of Health Canada and the World Health Organization for their recommendation of waiting until 6 months is also provided in this document:

http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/nutrition/child-enfant/infant-nourisson/excl_bf_dur-dur_am_excl-eng.php

Reply

10 Carla August 8, 2008 at 8:14 pm

Oh, by the way, in light of your focus on research-based parenting, I recently came upon a great organization you might like–the Talaris Institute (http://www.talaris.org/).

Reply

11 thea September 17, 2008 at 5:13 am

I hate to try to correct you on point 4, about the WHO recommendation to breastfeed until 2 yrs and beyond, but most of the protective effects of breasfeeding beyond about a year are for children in the third world, where supplementary food is not always safe and almost never nutritious enough. I do agree with you though that there is a need to push the pendulum in the other direction, so it’s better for mothers to believe toddlers can benefit greatly from long-term breastfeeding than to stick by the cautious advice of some well meaning doctors that 6 months is enough.

What I believe is more important, than even the belief in the benefits of long-term breastfeeding, is to instill it in people that breastfeeding in public is natural (Germany, where I live, is a great example, none bats an eyelid and I did not even cover; the USA, where I used to live, is horribly prudish in this respect).

In any case breastfeeding is a great way to bond with your child, beyond its nutritious value and health-protective effects, and the decision to wean is a very personal one, with many factors playing a role.

Reply

12 phdinparenting September 17, 2008 at 9:08 am

@ thea

Thank you for your comment.

I agree that the decision to wean is a very personal one.

However, I disagree with your comments regarding the optimal duration of breastfeeding. In addition to the World Health Organization recommendation (which takes into account the needs of babies in all countries, developing and developed), Health Canada also recommends breastfeeding for up to 2 years and beyond (and Canada certainly does not qualify as a developing country):

“Exclusive breastfeeding is recommended for the first six months of life for healthy term infants, as breast milk is the best food for optimal growth. Infants should be introduced to nutrient-rich, solid foods with particular attention to iron at six months with continued breastfeeding for up to two years and beyond .”

Health Canada references the following study for its 2 year recommendation: [4] Goldman, A.S. The immune system of human milk: antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory and immunomodulating properties. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1993; 12:664-71.

Kellymom, a research-based breastfeeding and parenting Web site, also provides research-based information on the benefits of nursing beyond a year. In summary they are:

Nursing toddlers benefit NUTRITIONALLY
Nursing toddlers are SICK LESS OFTEN
Nursing toddlers have FEWER ALLERGIES
Nursing toddlers are SMART
Nursing toddlers are WELL ADJUSTED SOCIALLY
Nursing a toddler is NORMAL
MOTHERS also benefit from nursing past infancy

Full details are available here: Extended Breastfeeding Fact Sheet (contains links to all references for the above points).

Reply

13 Caroline September 21, 2008 at 7:05 pm

It sounds to me like this is a collection of your opinions…

Reply

14 phdinparenting September 21, 2008 at 11:21 pm

@ Caroline: Number 6 is an opinion based on what I have seen myself and heard from other parents. All of the rest are research-based and are not opinions.

Despite the fact that these are all facts (not opinions), it is of course my opinion that these are the 10 most important things all new parents should know. Other people may put other things first.

Reply

15 mommyof3tots December 7, 2008 at 1:56 pm

@Caroline: Anything that comes from a person’s mouth IS their opinion. Whether it is an opinion based on facts or experience. Even medical studies are based on the interpretation, including opinion, of the facts. Where else are humans supposed to get information? Please name me one source, in all the world, where an opinion is not included.

Reply

16 Tracy March 25, 2009 at 12:14 pm

None of this looks like opinion to me. More like parenting instincts (that many of us have been taught to ignore), that now science can prove they were right all along.

One I would add is that car seats are for cars! Possible problems due to car seat overuse is barely mentioned to new parents, well in the UK anyway. Yet you see it all the time.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/1526517.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/6216892.stm
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1SFS/is_4_81/ai_n25358064

Not to mention the fact when carted about in car seats all day (and I know of some who spend all night in one too) they miss out on vital cuddles.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2005/nov/22/research.science

Reply

17 Loukia June 10, 2009 at 4:05 pm

This is a great post. I totally agree with “You cannot spoil a child with love”. I hate when people say ‘you’re spoiling him!’ when I pick up or hug my child whenever he cries. I don’ t believe in ‘tough love’ – can’t do it, no thank you. I don’t care if I’m tired… I will always respond to my child if they’re crying. What will it teach a baby if you don’ t go into his/her room to see what is wrong when they are that young?

Reply

18 lunzy June 20, 2009 at 7:49 pm

Great list! Nice little package of info to share with folks. Thanks!
~Lisa

Reply

19 breastpump44 June 23, 2009 at 2:37 am

Nice blog and good stuff provided on this blog for new parents. Thanks for writing such a good blog and helping many parents who don’t know about child necessary.

Reply

20 Lisa July 7, 2009 at 10:49 pm

I only disagree with your continuing of the obesity scaremongering. It isn’t nearly the problem the media makes it out to be. Also, obesity has many, many factors, many of which are related to genetics. Continuing to promote the idea that fat people are fat because they’re lazy junk food eaters & if they’d just eat better & exercise more they’d be thinner does no one any favours. ITA with you about feeding your kids a healthy diet, but because everyone should eat as healthily as possible, not because of discriminatory ideas about fat people.

Reply

21 phdinparenting July 7, 2009 at 11:12 pm

@Lisa: What did I say that led you to believe that I think fat people are lazy junk food eaters? I agree that obesity has many factors. I also know that it comes with risks and that it can be prevented or minimized in many people and the best way to do that is through a healthy diet and exercise.

Reply

22 Erin August 1, 2009 at 8:54 pm

You’ve been duped by the industry too. Saturated fat is so essential to a healthy child. Dairy fat, animal fats, and natural oils like palm oil and coconut oil are one of the ways this country could get healthy again. I totally agree with you on the sugar thing. But a low saturated fat diet will set your child up for a life of disease. Avoid all margerines, fried fast foods, vegetable oils, etc. (manufactured or altered fats). But please remember to give your child: butter, cream, egg yolks EVERYDAY. You won’t believe how healthy your child will be. Want more info? Check out http://www.westonaprice.org/children/nourish-baby.html

Reply

23 phdinparenting August 1, 2009 at 9:44 pm

@Erin: I’ve not been duped by the industry and I’m certainly not going to be duped by the Weston A. Price Foundation. I’d prefer to listen to what the American Hearth Association has to say, which is to limit (not eliminate) saturated fats and replace them with monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats. For more info on that see: Saturated Fats.

Reply

24 Heather July 12, 2010 at 7:02 am

Please read the Weston A Price stuff, keeping in mind that they are NOT industry-funded, but that the American Heart Association are some of the biggest industry whores around, getting much of their funding from both the pharmaceutical industry & the processed food industry. (here are a couple of links–a google search will get you more http://www.awkolaw.com/blog/avandia/american-heart-associations-defense-of-avandia-questionable-motives/ http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0876/is_2001_Wntr/ai_75705615/ ). The research on which the war against saturated fats is based is seriously flawed, in several different ways, beginning with the fact that none of that research separated saturated fats from trans fats. For another example, the original research on which the war on fat is based, conducted by Ancel Keyes, had data for 22 different countries. He only used the data from the 6 countries that had data agreeing with his premise on which to support his conclusions. It was research just as bad as the latest from AJOG.
We have been villainizing saturated fats and eliminating them from our diets for the past half a century. While all the diseases that were supposedly caused by too much saturated fat in our diets got worse, NOT better. Please, please research this from sources that do not take money from the processed food industry or from Big Pharma (which excludes the government, which gets lots of money from both, as taxes, fees, and campaign contributions. If you start checking into how such agencies as the FDA get their money, you will know that you cannot rely on their information).

Reply

25 phdinparenting July 12, 2010 at 9:00 am

Heather:

I don’t have a lot of respect for the Weston A Price Foundation given their stance on breastfeeding.

I also don’t think we should eliminate saturated fats from our diet, but I do think we need to reduce the amount of saturated fats that we consume and we need to focus on consuming healthier saturated fats. Instead of a plate that is half filled with french fries and half filled with pepperoni pizza, we should be aiming for a plate that is half filled with vegetables, a quarter filled with starch and a quarter filled with protein. I don’t think that some butter on those vegetables or starches is the problem or that a good steak is the problem. I think the problem is the fact that saturated fats get consumed in excess and at the expense of things like fruits and vegetables.

Reply

26 Heather July 12, 2010 at 3:27 pm

Their stance on breastfeeding is that there ARE some women who actually can’t breastfeed successfully–which is true. It is even more true in our malnourished society. Remember, a lot of people who are overweight are actually malnourished, not the opposite! WAP also provides some of the best practical help out there–recipes for good, nourishing, homemade baby formulas that work. MUCH better than giving the babies soy and corn syrup (the principal ingredients in most prefab formulas).
French fries might be full of trans fats, but would have little to no saturated fats in this day and age–but the frying oils that are used for them are definitely not good for you. The oils that have replaced the trans fat oils (in places that are not still just using them) mess with one’s blood sugar. What is making people fat is sugar, white flour, and industrial fats (such as the yuck restaurants fry fries in), not whole foods and real fats. The biggest problem with pizza is all that white flour in the crust. Of course, grass fed pepperoni and good quality sauce and cheese would be an improvement, too. But the things that keep people fat, as well as many of the chronic diseases of obesity, have their roots in blood sugar issues. If anything, good fats help to stabilize blood sugar.

Reply

27 phdinparenting July 12, 2010 at 4:20 pm

Heather:

There are plenty of women who are malnourished around the world and successfully breastfeed their babies. If a mom has sufficient money to buy food (e.g. the stuff that goes into the “good, nourishing, homemade baby formulas”), then she would be better served eating that stuff herself so that it will nourish her and nourish her baby.

With regards to everything else that you said, I don’t disagree entirely. I never said that white flour, sugar, trans fats or other industrial fats are healthy. Don’t forget the sodium too (most fast food and processed food is excessively high in sodium). People should eat a balanced diet of whole foods, which can and should include good fats in moderation along with plenty of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains.

Reply

28 Mel November 30, 2011 at 7:19 pm

I just say this and wanted to say thank you. The person who wrote this article along with so many others had made me feel like the worst mother EVER cause I couldn’t breastfeed. I tried with my oldest and everything stopped at 6 weeks, nothing would make the lactation come back. And with my second the milk barley came in to be enough to feed him. So when I read this stuff saying ALL women can do it makes me feel horrible.

Reply

29 Abbie August 5, 2009 at 9:02 am

Thanks for this article! I’m not a parent yet, but so much of it makes sense. So many of my friends are new moms that seem to worry so much about everything, it’s nice to see your relaxed approach.

As for co-sleeping, I know it won’t be able to happen in my house. My husband is an active sleepwalker, getting up and walking around about once a week and talking every night. I’ve gotten bumps and bruises from him, so when we have children I’m not planning to have them join us in bed. My parents co-slept with us before it was called “co-sleeping,” so I’m aware if it’s benefits and that it can be safe, but I know it won’t work for us.

Reply

30 Kate August 21, 2009 at 10:56 am

Hi Abbie,

We had a hard time with co-sleeping at first, until we realized that – duh – we don’t ALL have to sleep in the same bed! It’s just sleep, and people should sleep where they’re going to be most rested, so my husband volunteered to sleep downstairs so my daughter and I could take up the bed, and we all ended up getting GREAT sleep.

Now my daughter is 13 months and has transitioned to her crib (which is still in our room) and my husband’s back in the bed. It was only a few months (maybe 6?) that we changed our set-up. No harm done. It’s great to have my husband back in the bed, but it was also wonderful to have the opportunity to nurture a co-sleeping relationship with my daughter too.

Just keep in mind that you can be creative and work out temporary solutions to meet the parenting goals you want to attain.

Reply

31 Melodie August 20, 2009 at 11:02 pm

This is a great list Annie. I’m going to post this on my Facebook page for my friends who are newly expecting a baby. I also agree with @Tracy’s comments. I know too many parents who leave their kids in strollers or car seats all day instead of picking them up and giving them those much needed cuddles and loves. I know they love their babies but please new parents, don’t leave your infant in a seat all day!

Reply

32 Johanne August 29, 2009 at 9:09 am

Agreed with that too. I just recently went to a baptism where the little 2 mo was left in the stroller ALL. DAY. (It was an outside ceremony at the grand-parents’ house). Awake or sleeping, he was in there, except for the ceremony, and then 1-2 times I’ve seen in him in his mother’s arm. Otherwise, she was chattering around, and not often at least close by. Often the stroller was just kind of next to someone, facing out, and whoever was sitting next to him casually rocked the stroller a bit if he fussed.

My heart panged :( Here I was, totting my 14 mo in the sling (and of course getting the inevitable “you should put her down”, “free yourself”, “you’ll hurt your back”, etc.), and otherwise giving her my 95% attention (5% was baby-adoring Grandma making a fuss over her, so far, only grand-child ;-) ). Looking back, I wish I would have had the nerve to pick him up and carry it in the sling when DD was not in it. I guess I was too worried to offend anyone, as they can be quite judgemental… Still wish I did it, though. (note to self…)

I think this can be another example of how sometimes “calm” baby are at a disadvantage, because they “can” be left unattended in a stroller or car seat and don’t cry out for much attention. I can’t remember where I read it, but in societies with lower means, these babies are more at risk of dying (it might have been in one of your post, Annie, that I read this. If so, do point me in the right direction! :) ).

On another note, these are the same cousins who told my husband at some part of the day that he was sleeping through the night since he came out of the hospital. My husband said a non-committal “Oh, that’s nice”, and the response to that? “To key for that to work is to not breastfeed.” Oh, I wish I had been there too! (my husband told me in the car on the way back.)

Reply

33 phdinparenting August 29, 2009 at 9:18 am

@Johanne: I don’t think that info about babies being more at risk of dying was in my post, but I have heard that before too. I am glad that I had my high needs child before my calm one. Otherwise I may not have ever made it beyond the mainstream.

Reply

34 Johanne August 29, 2009 at 1:01 pm

Very true – it may not be obvious at 4 am after 3 hours of rocking a screaming ball of energy, but they can be blessings in disguise, for both them and us. :)

Reply

35 Alice Law August 21, 2009 at 11:33 am

Agree with the post, “All Thumbs Up”!!

Reply

36 Johanne August 29, 2009 at 12:59 pm

Love your last paragraph, well said! I feel like framing it on my fridge, or something, as a reminder for me, and as a gentle *hint hint* for people walking in our house ;-)

Reply

37 Julie Cole October 24, 2009 at 10:50 pm

Great post! I always say, that mama is the expert on her baby, and you have to commit to not caring about what other people think.

Reply

38 phdinparenting October 24, 2009 at 11:03 pm

Thanks Julie. I love your comment and agree completely about that last part especially. Confidence is key.

Reply

39 Stephanie October 29, 2009 at 2:42 pm

I agree. With every point.

In fact, I think all new parents should read this post.

I might add, “Baby gear is overrated. Do your best to steer clear of the commercial trap (start by throwing away those “must-have” registry lists).” ;)

Reply

40 kat February 11, 2010 at 3:21 am

Nice post. I would especially like to say that there should really be more “web material” about breastfeeding not being “all or nothing”. The fact is, some mothers and babies have a VERY hard time with this. After a pain medication free delivery I was shocked at the trouble we had with breastfeeding, and I cried and cried when we came to the point where I couldn’t do it exclusively. I’m okay with how it turned out now, but it would be nice to feel more support and help than preaching and pressure on this issue.

Reply

41 Cathy March 5, 2010 at 8:31 am

What a wonderful post! I love this…my boys are 11 and 15 now, but I am so pleased to say that I followed much of this advice all those years ago, but I am glad to share your post with lots of others! I know many people who could benefit from reading such a great list!

Reply

42 B March 14, 2010 at 9:51 pm

Tracy you are so right about “parenting instinct”. We bought the usual baby things like the buggy, and the baby cot with matching sheets and mobile. Decorated the baby room. We didn’t read anything about parenting before we had our first child and it ended up that we found ourselves following these 10 things and more by our own instincts. The buggy went unused for months and then only used sporadically as we carried our son everywhere in the sling. The baby cot was used only as a safe holding place for the baby while I showered! Our room was the baby’s room! We had people telling us that we were spoiling the baby and we need to put him in his own room to sleep and let him cry it out. We attempted it, and instantly realized that is was wrong for us. Our son reacted much better when we attended to his needs immediately. Babies are not sophisticated enough to “manipulate” their caregivers. Babies need food, comfort, security, love, and mental stimulation when they feel they need it, not only when it is convenient for the caregivers to give those things.

Reply

43 good mother June 26, 2010 at 11:46 pm

i think that this article is a load of crap. i have 3 small children and it is impossible to respond to every single cry and my strong headed children had to cry it out in bed many, many nights because they learned that by crying at night i would come to them and so i was getting no sleep…there was no medical reason for the crying other than they just didnt want to be in the crib..co-sleeping is not good..had a friend who had a baby die of SIDS

Reply

44 phdinparenting June 27, 2010 at 2:25 pm

good mother:

Co-sleeping is great. Babies die of SIDS in cribs (it used to be called “crib death”). Some babies die of suffocation while co-sleeping, but not if parents take appropriate precautions. See:

Co-Sleeping Safety
Fox News Video on Co-Sleeping

Reply

45 Melly K July 20, 2010 at 10:23 am

I have 6 children under the age of 9, several of which are *very* strong-willed. I have never left a child crying for hours at night, and by responding to my children’s cries efficiently and quickly, they soon became secure enough to not cry at all. No, I do not attend to their every whim, but I did attend to their every NEED—-including a need for loving arms and the respect that they might know when they needed me, as opposed to what a doctor might medically ordain.
As a side note, SIDS means a child dies for no reason. Death by co-sleeping is from not doing it correctly, and the cause is known. It is not the same at all. Co-sleeping actually encourages a child to regulate both their temperature and their breathing at a time when they are still learning to do all of that.

Reply

46 Monique July 11, 2010 at 3:24 pm

I wish more people would do the research you did. I love everything you had to say. I wish more people were open minded. A lot of it is personal choice, BUT everyone should look at the facts. I think the world would be better off if more parents looked at the needs of their children before their own. In most cases, parents will find that listening to their childrens needs will help life be better for everyone. It makes me sad when people say that all of this is dangerous when in reality it is all safer when you do it all right. Keep up the good work.
The breast feeding, pumped till my son was almost two, co-sleeping, baby wearing, cloth diapering, attached parenting mom with her second due in September and can’t wait to do it all again.

Reply

47 Melissa E. July 11, 2010 at 4:18 pm

While I don’t agree with everything you said, there are some excellent points in your post. I especially agree about the rear facing carseat. My son is 19 months old and 24 pounds, and he is still rear facing in a Britax convertible car seat. When I took him last month for his 18 month pediatrician’s appointment, the doctor seemed shocked that he was still rear facing. “He puts up with that?,” she asked? “Most of my patient’s parents say that their toddlers can’t stand being rear facing.”

My response? “He is one year old. How does he know that the car seat even turns? He doesn’t complain because he doesn’t know anything different, and he’s fine.” Indeed he is. Occasionally he gets mad at being constrained, but it would be crazy of me to assume that his toddler fit is because he “wants” me to turn the car seat around. I read the articles about how much safer rear-facing is for the child, and we decided to leave Nick that way until his weight or height prohibits it. He is small for his age, though, so he should be able to stay rear facing for some time.

Thanks for the good advice. :)

Reply

48 Jolene July 13, 2010 at 12:54 am

Our son became a lot happier in the car after we turned him around at about 14 months.

Reply

49 Jen July 11, 2010 at 4:40 pm

Great list! I’ll vouch that the research supports the statements you’ve made, not just specific studies but also the evolving understanding of brain development supports it as well! Parenting is hard work! I might add something about how developmental milestones often temporarily disrupt the status quo in various ways. My kids were all great sleepers but with each milestone we had 4-7 nights of needing more “mommy” time. It was nice to know this wasn’t the start of something permanent. :-) I also love to hear that you CAN go back to work and still breastfeed. Even with a crappy milk supply I nursed when I was with my babies and gave up the pumping all together (to reduce stress) by 9 months.

Reply

50 Jane in Pa July 11, 2010 at 5:11 pm

One quick note on #5- There is actually some evidence coming forth that suggests delaying some foods actually increases the risk of food allergies and respiratory problems. I am just throwing this into the mix as a point of review/discussion–obviously, do your homework and what you feel is best for your child. Great list though- I am a big fan of co-sleeping :)

Reply

51 mystic_eye July 11, 2010 at 11:19 pm

I have seen evidence delaying “allergenic” food until 1-2 years (such as peanuts) increases allergies. I haven’t seen any studies that show in breastfed babies delaying solids increases allergies as long as you continue nursing.

Reply

52 mystic_eye July 11, 2010 at 11:18 pm

Its not necessarily true that formula fed babies shouldn’t receive solids before 6 months. Formula causes the same changes to the digestive tract as other foods and some babies might benefit from fiber (which is found in breastmilk but not formula) or some easily digested nutrients (such as iron). The evidence isn’t in yet, but clearly if you’re giving apple or prune juice all the time for constipation you’d probably be better off giving whole apples or plums.

Also many experts now recommend formula feeding for at least 18 months.

And I would add that pureed baby food is absolutely not beneficial for breastfed babies. Letting the baby self-feed ensures they are ready to eat food, won’t overreact, and reduces the likelihood of constipation and other problems.

Also car-seats are for CARS. Its not safer to clip the car-seat to the stroller than to put the baby directly in the stroller. The younger the baby the less time they should spend in a car-seat even if you are driving, you should take breaks to allow the baby to re-oxygenate and stretch.

Reply

53 CARL BAKER July 12, 2010 at 1:09 am

God Bless all mothers that breast feed , During our dating phase , breast feeding came up and we decided to feed for 18 months for both my boys , God Bless my wife for all the attention and loving care given to my children , that will carry on as increased health and resistance to illnesses for a life time…

Reply

54 Cindy July 12, 2010 at 6:59 pm

Carl, I must write that it’s nice to see a dad post! My husband reads some of the posts Annie writes and he is a strong “silent” supporter of her blog through me!

Breastfeeding is done by the mother, the caring and nurturing that is also given to baby when baby is breastfed is done by the mother AND the father. My husband is a very proud DADDY and proud of me as well for breastfeeding our daughter to 18 months and it makes me love him so much more because of the family bond that we have created through this. (I’m a sappy pregnant woman right now, haha)

Your wife and children are lucky to have you!

Reply

55 Cindy July 12, 2010 at 6:56 pm

I first read this when my daughter was a few weeks old, and now, at 19 months, my husband and I can say that we did (and are!) doing what is healthiest, most safest and most “instinctal” with/for our daughter. I enjoy reading all your blog entries Annie. Thank you for reposting this.

I’m very proud of these facts! But boohoo, Lily weaned at 18 months (because I was 23 weeks pregnant) I hope she re-starts when new baby arrives. (She’ll be 22 months)
I’m going to share on my facebook!

Reply

56 carolb July 12, 2010 at 10:09 pm

couldn’t agree more!

Reply

57 Heather D July 12, 2010 at 10:40 pm

This is a great list! To the point and informative.

My only complaint is that I really think there should be a #11 — as other commenters have stated already, “car seats are for cars.”

The “car seat carrier” has become so ubiquitous, that parents just seem to absorb the idea unconsciously, that babies BELONG in some kind of carrier at all times. I was at an infant baptism recently, two babies. Both started the service in their car seats. They were actually removed and held in-arms for the baptism itself. Immediately afterwards, one baby was kept in-arms in their pew while the mom fed him a bottle (sigh). Then back into the seat on the floor. The other baby went immediately back into the seat, which was held on the father’s lap. Where he proceeded to just hold this big honkin’ seat on his lap, smiling at his baby, gazing at her lovingly, rocking the seat on his lap… I just couldn’t understand it! Why put her in the seat, to then hold the seat on your lap? The only conclusion — the inherent belief that babies are supposed to be IN something.

I think this partly is the fault of the standard hospital policy of having to check out with your baby in its car seat. It’s a good policy, in the sense that it ensures new parents have a safe car seat and know how to get baby in it properly. But I don’t understand why there’s usually a stipulation that you must actually carry the baby out in the seat — not just bring it in for a check. This gives parents the STRONG message that 1) you must use a bucket seat and not a convertible, since the convertible are NOT for carrying baby in, and 2) you must carry your baby in the bucket at all times, you can’t trust yourself to not drop it, or use any other kind of conveyance.

I had to actually argue with the nurses about this. We brought in our Radian convertible car seat — perfectly safe for babies 5lbs and up. They wanted to make me carry her in it when we left. This is a 40-pound steel-framed seat! Not designed for carrying the baby in! They were just so confused, they obviously were not used to seeing anything other than buckets. I left with my daughter in a sling. In the end they couldn’t stop me.

But with that as the beginning experience for 99% of parents, it’s little wonder that car seats are so overused as carriers, with the medical professionals themselves giving the implicit message that that’s what they’re supposed to do… despite all the MEDICAL RESEARCH studies showing how dangerous it truly is.

Anyway, I’d also like to comment about the baby foods — agreeing with a previous comment, that purees are completely unnecessary, self-feeding real food from the beginning is totally the way to go! So much easier and more developmentally appropriate.

Reply

58 Jolene July 13, 2010 at 12:47 am

I think your article has great information. The only thing I would change would be not to say that babies use crying as a last resort, because as the parent of an intense child/baby, I know that he would cry (scream) as a first resort. I used to feel very low self-esteem about this and thought that I was doing something wrong (for example, missing other cues), but now that I also have a very easy-going daughter who almost never cried as an infant, I see that this is a personality difference.

Thanks for making great information concisely available for more parents!

Jolene =)

Reply

59 Lea July 13, 2010 at 5:24 am

#12 There is no such thing as a “good” parenting book. Every book you read will have some good points and a lot of bad. Write your own book. There is no other child like yours and no other parent like you.

Reply

60 Jennifer July 20, 2010 at 7:38 am

This is a great article, with one exception. Children do NOT need a diet low in saturated fats; that’s the government’s “health” line (influenced by lobbyists with lots of money) and it is scientifically incorrect. Children need a diet with lots of good, healthy (grass-fed, not grain-fed) animal fats in order to grow their bodies and their brains correctly. Low-saturated-fats diets actually increase the obesity problem.

Reply

61 Brittany July 22, 2010 at 1:29 am

I agree with Jennifer about the Low-saturated fats, and I think the real emphasis should be on avoiding artificial transfats and hydrogenated oils.

Reply

62 anon September 12, 2010 at 7:59 am

I think your points are good ones, and ones I follow 99% of the time except I DO believe it is unsafe to sleep with babies. My Mom works for 9-11 call center and I couldn’t even tell you how many babies have died in the last 2 years from parents suffocating them in their sleep. Makes me sick. And no, these weren’t crack head drunk parents. I think its a personal choice. I personally believe the parent’s bed should be their sanctuary with each other as well. There has to be boundaries. I can lay with my child in her bed (now 3 yrs old) for as long as she needs, but she’s not laying in mine.
Also, the crying baby thing. I believe that of course you must respond to a baby’s cries to make sure their needs are met (physically and emotionally), but once you have responded a gazillion times and every time you go back there they smile and laugh, its time to say “no more.” If anyone on here thinks that kids can’t manipulate, then they are fools. My kids know I have always been there for them, but they also know they when its bedtime, its bedtime. Period. And I know the difference between a “tired, whiny, I don’t wanna sleep” cry and a “something is wrong, I am scared/hurt/lonely” cry. My kids never cried longer than 5 minutes and I would only wait it out if the cries were not hysterical. There is a balance. Some of the balance is made my common sense.
Yes, kids are important and we must raise them to feel safe and secure, well-adjusted individuals. But they are also individuals that will not be cradled and caudled when they are not with us, so they must learn some sort of self-assurance.
Just my opinion, and it works for my family. There is a reason that so many kids act so dang entitled all the time, and have no sense of consequence or fear. They get whatever they want and parents act afraid of THEM. Because we are so frightened of doing something wrong, screwing up our kids, b/c of all the articles and advice out there and not wanting to raise a serial killer – that we baby step around our own children and let them call the shots. Not gonna happen in this house. I am the Boss. I treat my children like people, individuals, who need to learn the rules and obey them or they will not get fun treats and toys. Life is the same way. Or should be.

Reply

63 Blair January 31, 2011 at 10:39 am

Yesterday I caught a ride from a woman I barely know from my church. She has a son who is roughly the same age as my second daughter (she’s 11m so he’s probably 9-10 months) and the subject of naptime came up. She mentioned her child didn’t have a nap schedule. This is something I’ve been struggling with myself–I’m not a scheduler, anyway, but it’s especially hard to work my baby’s naps in around my preschooler’s school schedule–and I thought I had found some common ground. We continued talking and she mentioned that her pediatrician had said that naps weren’t a big deal and not to worry if her son didn’t seem to take many, or enough naps. She said she felt relieved to have his approval. I commented that I could see why she would feel that way, and she went on to say that her pediatrician has dictated most of their parenting decisions, because who is she to say what’s right and wrong, and he’s the doctor, right? For example, he was a big believer in Ferber (gulp) and he was the one who insisted that they didn’t need to get up several times a night at 4 months old, and it turned out to be the best thing they ever did! She said, “My best friend doesn’t listen to a thing her doctor says. She thinks she knows it all, anyway.”

I said, “Ha ha! Actually, I’m kind of like that. Uhhh, well, I like to read books and get a lot of different ideas and just figure out what makes the most sense for our family.”

She said, “But I know I could read a bunch of different books and they would all say something different and that would just stress me out. Easier just to go to one source–my doctor. And he hasn’t led me wrong yet!” Sigh.

I’m not sure why I’m telling you all of this, but the whole conversation really stood out in my mind, particularly because I know this woman is VERY INTELLIGENT and a very capable critical thinker in other areas of her life. She is a successful attorney. I know she loves her son and she has expressed many times that she simply wants to do what’s best, and what’s healthiest for him. How are we as a society so divorced from our instincts that we are afraid to think critically about how we raise our children? Is it fear, or is it a lack of time and energy–an attempt to outsource parenting decisions? I don’t know. But I am sad for that baby. I am sad for the mama, although she may go to the grave certain she did the right thing for her child.

Reply

64 Samantha Gluck February 17, 2011 at 7:10 pm

Really great piece! Thanks for advocating exclusive breastfeeding!

Reply

65 Sonya March 3, 2011 at 2:00 pm

Excellent points here! Thanks for writing this. I fully agree and will be passing this on :)

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 7 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: